There are a few things we’ve come to count on during each season of The Bachelor, from fantasy suite dates to hot tub hijinks. Another sure-thing? The arrival of Neil Lane, L.A. jeweler and ABC’s go-to Santa Claus, who comes bearing a sparkling collection of diamond engagement rings for the season’s suitor to peruse before giving his top pick at the final rose ceremony.
“It’s so cool to think of these wonderful women from all the shows over the years wearing my rings,” the L.A. designer told PEOPLE. “I’ve even heard some of them joke around and sweetly call it the Neil Lane club!”
STEVE FENN/ABC; Inset: Courtesy Neil Lane