Kate’s Jubilee Dress: First Seen on Kim Kardashian

How can People even compare these two? A tramp vs. a Duchess? Kate has the style and grace that Kim could only wish she could have. The only thing Kim can do is hooker-fy her outfits. Shame on People for comparing the two.

Kim: take note on how to exude some class + respect.

Is this a serious question???????

KATE ALL THE WAY!!!! How can you compare the two?

I’m sorry but you just cannot compare these two. Kate is soooo much classier than Kim will ever be, so to compare them is crazy.

I’m actually not a Kim-hater, but the short and tight look with platform heels is not a great style for her. She is so beautiful. She looks best in taylored clothes that are well-fitted without being tight. And as any busty girl will tell you, high necklines only make you look bigger.

Talk about comparing a “silk purse” to a “sow’s ear”! Give me a break – you shouldn’t even put their names together in the same sentence!

[...] Kate's Jubilee Dress: First Seen on Kim KardashianPeople MagazineKim Kardashian (who had another high-fashion faceoff last week) wore a similar version of the frock last August while in New York City. The reality starlet's creation — a bit shorter — lacked the sleeves and boatneck detail of Kate's dress.Kate Middleton's Red Dress at Diamond Jubilee is Kim Kardashian's Grocery …Christian Post [...]

Kate does not look miserable and she looks great. I wonder what size the people telling her to eat are? I was really small when I was younger and fat people would always tell me to eat. Funny thing was I probably ate more than them and still stayed skinny. Anyways, I always attributed it to jealousy.

I could get on board with Kim’s version if her shoes didn’t vamp it up so much….even if she’d just chose the shoes her sister has on in the same picture the whole outfit would be much better. Otherwise, Kate totally.

Kim is too large for the dress and it’s too short for her. I would be surprised to see her in something that covers her and has long sleeves. Her accessories and blush are all wrong too. Whatever “style” Kim has, it can be found at the mall.

I love Kate but I have to say, this is a pretty loaded comparison. The woman is a Princess who people look up to and admire. I don’t hate Kim persay but a princess is going to trump her on her best fashion day.

No one is comparing the two of them. They are comparing the dresses. I think they both look fine. the dress has different vibe with each women. I just feel Kim’s looks a bit more current, whereas Kate looks dowdy. Sorry but this is about the dress and not the women.

Kim. One of the most stunning women in the world. Doesn’t look like a preteen, anorexic.

The dress is a little trendy, yet refined and polished at the same time. Kim looks like she’s trying too hard to look refined an polished, which she is not. It looks effortless on Kate. I think Kim probably feels a little upstaged by Kate…and rightly so.

I love it Kim! You are gorgeous. A hardworking modern woman who has created a great life out of hard work. Not someone who takes her education- disregards her hard work—to be her husband’s trophy! TEAM KIM!!!

Kim is one beefy girl.

If you want Kim to win this poll then you have to ask: Who’s got bigger ass…LOL

Looking at the dresses, I would personally wear Kate’s version. Kim’s is too short for my style since I do not like showing a lot of leg. I honestly don’t think it makes sense to compare the two though.

Beautiful classy Kate versus Hip Hop’s Porky Pig? Come on, People. You knew this was going to be one-sided.

PS I do not watch, buy, or follow the Kardashians in any way. Some of you haters do, shame on you

That’s an embarrassment to Kate to compare the two! Kate is worthy of her princess title. And Kim is worthy of…um…I’m not even sure!

Oh wait so I need to grow up just becuase you disagree with my opinion. So people are so pathetic.

There is no comparison, Kate has style and class. Kim…well…she has no class what so ever. All that money, what a waste.

[...] at the Guys Choice Awards – WonderwallAre Johnny Depp and the Black Keys forming a band? – Zap2itWhat Kate Middleton and Kim Kardashian have in common – PeopleHow does Jennifer Aniston's hair look good even at the gym? – Lainey GossipSarah Jessica [...]

People, did you really have to ask? If yes, your credibility is now shot.

I can not believe they would compare those two, Kim should not even be mentioned in the same sentence as Kate. Kim should not be mentioned anywhere!!!!!!

There is a difference between class and crass.

Kim of course!!!!

How can you even put them in the same category?? Shame on your People!

Guys be serious. They are asking which DRESS looks better on who? Not who IS better than one another. And honestly I prefer the fit on Kim K.

Note to People Mag: apples and oranges. There is no comparison.

o.k. so NOT the same dress. Are you blind?

If we are going for who wore it best I would say Kim but as far as morals I would say Kate but I dont know about that really Im jus sayin

Lol, normally I am not this mean but honestly People, how can you compare Lady and the Tramp? No question about it, Kate is classy, sophisticated and such a lovely lady. I will reserve my opinion about Kim.

The qiestion was which DRESS do you prefer. Putting aside my feelings for either person wearing it. I love a sleeveless short dress. That DRESS is cuter than Kate’s. Personalities are a competely different question…

While it’s refreshing to see Kim K. in something that is not skin tight, pleated dresses do no mix with animal skin shoes and witch doctor necklaces! Also, the pleats work well with Kim’s curves but the horizontal detailing above should never be worn by curvy women. The dress does look good sleeveless, and of course looks great with long sleeves too. If Kim just simplified the accessories by ditching the necklace and pairing the dress with nude pumps she would have looked lovely.

The dress makes Kim look fat. Not at all flattering on her. Kate wears it well.

Kate is not demure. She almost always wears her dresses above the knee and with high heels. Its obvious that she tries to get away with as much leg as she can without offending the Royal family. She also wears a ton of eye makeup so you can barely see the colour of her eyes. She is not the stunner that she thinks she is. Princess Diana was truly a stunner.

Kate Middleton is nowhere as gorgeous as Princess Diana was. Kate is overestimating herself.

The dresses are both red… but they are not in the least remotely the same… not to mention Kate has class.

Irene: Kim’s shoes make her feet look like horses hooves. Fabulous? I think not. Kate goes out with style, class, and grace. Unless Kim has a brain transplant, she will never reach that level of quality.

MommyOf2 I agree with you completely!! WELL SAID!!

Do you women think Kim cares what you think. I have never see so many jealous women on one thread ever. You People are green with envy. That is so sad to be that jealous. Don’t deny it that is what it is.

It is so not the same dress. Kate looks classy, elegant and ladylike – as opposed to Kim, who never looks elegant or ladylike. Kim always looks like she is going out to find someone to sleep with. She wishes that she can hold a candle to Kate (who I am not crazy about either!!)

Kate looks better because she looks more conservative.

I think they both look great, and personally, I like Kim’s version of the dress better than Kate’s. It’s not to say that Kate doesn’t look great, but people should give Kim some kudos for pulling together a great looking outfit too.

To People magazine: there is NOT COMPARISON.
KATE all the way!!

There is and never will be a woman so beautiful as Kate Middleton (Duchess of Cambridge). Duke of Cambridge William could not have chosen anyone better. She has looks, style, grace — everything (she smiles all the time) and is never a fake or put-on. She is what she is. She reminds me so much of Princess Diana and I know if she were alive she would have loved Kate — everything about her — EVERYTHING. I can’t wait until they have kids — especially about 3 or more.

Class comes from within. They both look lovely wearing the different dresses. I continue to be amazed at how many haters there seems to be – even posting about dresses.

Who wants to look like frumpy Kate? Only her because of circumstances!! I’ll prefer Kim’s in a second.#KimsRock

WHY is the news?! One is a fat moose, the other looks like she needs to eat a few burgers!

Kim K. will NEVER have enough class to compare to the Duchess of Cambridge.

Actually they are both alike, attention seekers, selling themselves to the highest bidder. The only difference is one has gorgeous curves, the other is skeletal.

Kate is a lovely women and Kim is a bi-polar mess. Kim will never have the class that Kate has. I’s shocked that they were put in the same category.

Money can’t buy class, no matter how much you sell yourself to make the money.

the only similar about these dresses is the color. why are you comparing them?

There hasn’t been a Mirror that Kim hasn’t used to primp with. Kate is a natural beauty with quality behind her. She just shines. Kim could only wish to have the class and style that comes to Kate naturally. I don’t think Kim is ever natural-she was just so PHONY!!

As usual, Kim looks like a hooker. Maybe they don’t make sizes large enough for that big ole butt! Man, I would hate to see what it will look like in 10-15 years. WWWWIDEEE As usual, Kate wears her appropriate size & looks like a classy hot young lady!
Great thing about Kim & Kanye; they both are bag d___ches! At least they won’t mess up or hurt 2 decent people! Finally 2 arrogant, narcissistic, self absorbed malignant people end up together instead of devastating 2 decent people!

Ha! Ha! Ha! Like comparing Mad Dog 20/20 bum wine to expensive champagne! Get real!

Any dress designer will confess that there are a limited number of styles…pleated skirt, a-line skirt, straight skirt, dirndl…a couple of neckline treatments with collar variations and various sleeve lengths. The combinations are what make a garment unique.

The difference between Kate’s dress and the Kardashian disaster is that Kate’s dress is feminine, modest, and appropriate. The Kardashian twitlet’s is garish and flamboyant. There is no real comparison between the two.

Who looks classier, more sophisticated and poised?-Kate
Who stands out as drop dead beautiful, one of the most gorgeous women in the world?- Kim

If brains were everything, 75% of the celebrities featured on this website wouldn’t exist.

Class vs “ass”.

OMG Nooooo! Tell me it can’t be true

Anyone would look better that ‘Thunder Thighs’ kimmy!!!!

Lets face it, the ‘Kard’ woman is quite chunky
for the outfit…Lose weight, take a class on
class….and ditch the current look that only
gets you in trouble…..

Catherine looks wonderful. Classy. Kim isn’t in the same class as Catherine , and never will be , no matter how much money she has.

WHO CARES!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Kim in no way even compares to Kate who is elegant and beautiful in every sense of the word. Kim is pretty but comparing her to Kate doesn’t even come close….

irene you need a lesson on taste, class and an eye check up. kim rarely looks good in anything because her body is so disproportionate. her breasts and bottom are far too big for her petite frame. nothing to do with hating on the kardashians! that’s just the way it is!

[...] Kate's Jubilee Dress: First Seen on Kim KardashianPeople MagazineCelebrity Fashion Face Off!ABC NewsThe Stir -IBTimes.co.uk -TheInsider.comall 273 news articles » [...]

Katherine Middleton hands down….not even a contest. Kim looks like the cheap hooker/stripper and x-rated internet porn star that she is.

Why is it always about the person and attacking someone. You would think we know these people. Who cares! the question was about the dress. It is obvious that most people are looking at the person rather than the dress. I do not watch the Kardashians and I agree that the Duchess has much class etc. Both dresses are beautiful, but I prefer the dress that Kim is wearing.

HOW can a comparison even be made between Kim Kardashian and Kate?! Of course Kate looks better. No vote required!

[...] via OK! e people [...]