January 8, 2008 | 1:00 pm

Posh, Amy Winehouse and Mary-Kate Olsen Top Mr. Blackwell’s Worst Dressed List!

Dave M. Benett/Getty

Another year, another Worst-Dressed List from the infamous Mr. Blackwell, who singles out his “Ten Titans of Taste-Free Terrors” from 2007 for his 48th Annual List. Topping his list is Victoria Beckham, whom he calls out for her “skinny-mini monstrosities”. Next up is Amy Winehouse, whom he calls a “part 50’s car-hop horror,” and Mary-Kate Olsen, whom Blackwell says “she resembles a tattered toothpick-trapped in a hurricane.” Ouch! Also making the list: Fergie, Kelly Clarkson, Eva Green, Avril Lavigne, Jessica Simpson, Lindsay Lohan and Alison Arngrim. But the fashion critic does offer this salve to the style-challenged, explaining “Let it be said, however, that my criticisms are based purely on their fashion flaws — I’m sure they’re all wonderful people beneath the deluge of dreck they drape themselves in.”

Mr. Blackwell also singles out the women he finds truly fashionable. Reese Witherspoon, Jemima Khan, Beyonce, Angelina Jolie, Helen Mirren, Nicole Kidman, Katie Holmes, Kate Middleton, Katherine Heigl and Cate Blanchett all make the cut. And for those of you who might be surprised that Britney Spears didn’t make a repeat performance, Mr. Blackwell explains “I felt that it was inappropriate at this time to make comment, when her personal life is in such upheaval. I hope 2008 is a better year for her.”

Tell us: Do you agree with Mr. Blackwell’s list? Is Posh truly the worst dressed star in Hollywood?

Pages: Next | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | … 17 | Next | Show All

Louis

Well the only thing i could say is that Mr Blackwell taste for clothes is out of fashion. His criticisms are completely out of sense because in his ” best dressed list ” they only are no risk taken people. They just don’t anything punky , original and interesting. Call it classic if you want , i call it lame and out. What about that crap list of the ” worst dressed ” with Mary-Kate Olsen , Lindsay Lohan and Victoria Beckham. Mary-Kate as a strong personal style ( for Mr Blackwell that what he calls fashion faux-pas ) Lindsay Lohan has a classic look ( he must like it i’m surprised ) and Victoria Beckham is trendsetter. And what the hell are Beyoncé , Reese Witherspoon and Kate Middleton doing into that list. Meanwhile , i love what i said about not putting Britney in the list . For one time is in life i think he had got a good man attitude.

ACHammar

Who made this washed up wannabe the expert on fashion. Once a year he crawls out from a fossil and gets his name in the paper. Most of these people dress the way their fans want to see them. It is all a show and shouldn’t be taken seriously. THE SAME AS MR BLACKWELL!

belle

h no! i think she’s the ultimate fashion icon!!!! he’s out of his mind!!!!! atleast she has some fashion sense ….amy winehouse should have been the only one on the list!!!!

Trasur

I couldn’t agree more. Posh needs to grow up alot when it comes to fashion. She dresses like an adolesent tramp.

Sassy

I think the Olsen twins should have topped the list. I don’t ever remember seeing either of them in anything that looks even halfway flattering.
Why doesn’t everyone just leave Britney Spears alone. It’s obvious the girl has SERIOUS problems, and needs time to re-group, and heal. I don’t understand why PEOPLE magazine even had to mention that she was considered to be on the worst dressed list.

Allison T.

I love Mr. Blackwell’s quote about “fashion dreck”—I think he’s hilarious! (I also agree him on his selection of Posh to top his list!) On the other hand, I think his decision to leave Britney off this year’s list was an extremely classy one.

Suz

Posh’s clothes aren’t the problem. It’s her need to have her fake boobs up under her chin. We’ve seen them, enough already.

Mariah Carey deserved to be number one. Time for her to dress her age. Enough with your boobs too already.

Bob

It’s fortunate for Ms. Beckham that there is such a thing as bad taste or she wouldn’t have any at all.

Sheila

Posh is not very attractive. She really isn’t. I have a hard time understanding what she’s done to make her famous. She was in the Spice Girls several years ago. Ok, that didn’t last long. She has no fashion sense, she dresses like a hooker. She also seems very full of herself. I’m impressed! Yeah, right!

Macy

I agree with Lily 110%. You called it just perfect!!

Pages: Next | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | … 17 | Next | Show All

Advertisement

   Add Comments header

Got something to add to this post? Fill out the fields below to make a comment, ask a question or share a tip. We'd love to hear from you.

Note: If this is your first time commenting on Style News Now, your comment will need to be approved by our moderator before it will appear. Thanks for your patience, and check back again soon.




Edited by Melissa Liebling-Goldberg

\

Ask the Editors

Got a burning question ?

From where to shop online to your favorite star's bag, we'll track down the answers for you.

Click Here