IMO, the point is to bring more of the effect on the top eyelid, while focusing on darkening the color a little bit {NOT TOO DARK}, and playing up the eyelashes, but not go crazy. Avril’s color is too dark on top. You don’t want to go crazy with the black liner beneath the eye, you just want to add a little touch of dark liner, not color in the whole part beneath your eye. If you go crazy on top and at the bottom, you’re going to look like a racoon, and that’s not a good thing.

In this case, with Avril, she looks like a racoon. The bottom part of her eyes look ridiculous. She went or her make-up stylist went over-board and basically colored in her bottom part of her eyes. IMO, wipe away some of that mess at the bottom of her eyes and possibly add a TOUCH of blue at the bottom of her eyes, but don’t go crazy, just add a touch of color and LIGHTEN the dark on the top of her eyelids, darken up her eyelashes to bring a long effect to them and a nice rich color, and she’s set to go. That’s just my opinion/advice anyways. I will wear the smokey eye {NOT LIKE AVRIL’S} on occasion when going to a club or party, but not all the time, I like to keep my make-up more natural looking, but I like to have fun with my make-up too.