Maggie Gyllenhaal : I absolutely loved her dress at the Oscars. The feathers weren’t over the top, and they went well with the dress. I didn’t even notice them on the dress until they were pointed out. They were suttle on the dress and didn’t look hideous what so ever.

Mischa Barton : Jeez… it seems everytime she ends up on OFF THE RACK, she’s always known for her terrible style. I know she’s young, but come on, this get-up is ridiculous. What I don’t understand is, she’s pretty, but she dresses horribly. The black tights with the feathered mini dress is awful looking.

Kirsten Dunst : She wasn’t my least favorite dressed at the Oscars, there were others that were more horrible looking than her. Don’t get me wrong, I love Kirsten. She’s a great actress, and isn’t afraid to take risks in her career, but her Oscar dress was icky. Maybe her dress would have looked better if she did her hair properly, but I just think too much was going on, on the dress. I hated those bangs on her, and that bun was horrible. It was like the hair stylist, make-up artist, and those that dressed her weren’t all on the same page.

Penelope Cruz : Although I was on the fences with her dress, it did grow on me. Penelope was right, the Oscars was probably the only chance to wear a dress like that and that extravagent. She wasn’t my best dressed, but she certainly did look beautiful.

Kimora looks silly too, but Maggie looks great. C’mon guys, lets not make this a new trend – pleeeease!!!!

Maggie: Gorgeous. If you’re going to wear feathers, she’s done it beautifully and tastefully. I’d wear Maggie’s dress to the right occasion.

Mischa: Terrible! Nude dress with opaque black tights and black shoes…in the winter? She might actually have pulled it off with the right shoes and no tights. Since I dislike nude and blush tones, I would not wear her dress.

Mischa looks awful (it hurts me to say that… at least she looked amazing in the star tracks today!). Kimora Lee is better, definitely not ready to be “plucked.” Maggie’s works… its somehow both very original and still classy. I think we’re all happy when she shows up looking like she’s wearing something other than Olsen castaways.

Now this may be my personal vendetta against Kirsten Dunst speaking, but she was easily the worst dressed at the Oscars… even the nutty lady wearing the multi colored circus tent was able to rock batty. Poor Kirsten just looked like somebody had dropped her off there and without mentioning “By the way, we’ll be going by the Oscars,” which in that case I can sympathize–my husband likes to take me on suprise dates but is very inept at helping me figure out what to wear when I don’t know where we’re going. Maybe someone pulled the same thing on Kirsten?