Fashion Faceoff: Lindsay vs. Jade!

12/01/2006 at 06:00 AM ET

Considering how often Lindsay Lohan is photographed (every day!) and how often she changes clothes (at least once or twice an event!), it comes as no surprise that we would catch her wearing the same dress as another celeb. It’s just inevitable! Lindsay wore this hot-off-the-runway dress from Gucci’s Fall ’06 collection to the afterparty of her Just My Luck premiere in May. Several months later, Mick Jagger’s daughter, jewelry designer Jade Jagger, turned up in hers at a fashion week event in London. You decide: Who wears it better? The actress or the designer?

To check out — and vote on! — more fashion faceoffs, click here for our gallery.

Photo: Lester Cohen/WireImage; Nick Harvey/WireImage

Add A Comment

Got something to add to this post? Fill out the fields below to make a comment, ask a question or share a tip. We'd love to hear from you.

Note: If this is your first time commenting on Style News Now, your comment will need to be approved by our moderator before it will appear. Thanks for your patience, and check back again soon.

Showing 32 comments

ashley on

Actually, Leanne Rimes wore it best in her video…

Nicol on

Lindsay is gorgeous and very sexy!!!!!!!!!!

Chelle on

Jade definately…it just seems to fit her body better

Rob on

Team Lindsay!

Rebecca on

Love the dress! Both look gorgeous in it, but I like it a little better on Jade- compliments her skin tone and hair color.

EChizzle on

3. Lindsay
2. Jade
1. ME!!!!

Juliet on

I don’t know how she does it, but Lindsey makes everything on her look Cheap and trashy.

So Jade!

Chrissy on


yen on

jade looks great,she┬┤s older than lindays and looks ten times better in that dress,jade skin tone and hair clompliment the dress,and the way the flash from the cameras hit the dress also helps to give the image a great vibe,JADE HAS GREAT LEGS

Amber on

I say Lindsay wears it better but the dress is gawd aweful anyways, I’d never wear that type of dress; ever.

Denia Terra on

I like Lindsay better if I had to choose between those two… but I liked better when Nicole from the Pussycat Dolls wore to the PSD presentation on American Music Awards 2006!!!
It is the same dress!!!!

AnnieM on

Ditto Juilette. Yawn – wake me when Lindsay’s 15 minutes up.

Courtney on


Denise on

I actually thought it was Robin Wright Penn in the picture! I have to agree with some of you, I think Lindsay looks trashy in most things, it’s her negative attitude that shines through no matter what she’s wearing. I wish she would stop with the self tanner. . . she always looks icky to me.

O'Wryly on

Not very “adequite” on Lindsay. Everything she wears looks very K-Mart clearance rack-ish to me. Jade Jagger looks classier by far.

beth on


Andrea on

ANYONE but Lindsay. She makes everything she wears look hideous. I can’t stand her style.

SoUtHsIdE PrInCeSs on

Jade looks so much prettier because she’s curvy enough and the dress hugs her curves beautifully.

Lindsey looks pretty too, but she might want to gain some weight.

Haley on

Definitely Jade… Lindsay, as usual and as a lot of you said, looks trashy and cheap. Jade looks glamourous and Lindsay looks like a teeny-bopper kid who’s trying to act a lot older than she should.

fatz on

i like it better on jade it really looks better on her!!!

micheleeee. on

It’s Lindsay’s upper body. It’s too…I dont know, BIG! And her hair is ratty which makes the dress look trashy.

But Jade’s sleeves are too big. so yeaa. It’s a tie.

Sky on

Gisele wore it in Vogue, and it looked even better!

char on

Lindsey wore it best

Merissa on

Linsay’s head looks too big for her body……… I’m gonna with Jade

megan on

I like the dress better on Jade, but think it would look better with Lindsay’s shoes.

Quinci Barlow on

Lindsay looks great in this dress. She has a great sense of style and fashion and looks great in everything she wears. Great dress, Lindsay!

Sunni on

Jade, Jade, and Jade. She has class that Lindsay lacks

Kate on

I can’t stand Lindsay, so I’d say Jade anyways. In this case, though, my decision was really made on the look of the outfit. Something about Lindsay’s version does seem so trashy and cheap.

alfieza on

jade is ‘the hottie’ in dat dress..

danielle on

i think lindsay does.
what is jade doing pulling it over her hands? she looks like a child a school.

and id like to add i dont think lindsay is trashy atall
she always looks lovely

pink_princess on

urgh lindsay looks horribe. it MIGHT look better if made more effort on her facial appearance, but she looks like she just got out of bed. jade looks much more glamourous

katie on

Jade defintitly weras it best and looks great but the only thing she needs is to fix the face… :D

From Our Partners

From Our Partners


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,392 other followers

Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters