Carrie Underwood: Do You Like Her Naughty or Nice?

She is so beautiful either way. Few people could pull off both of those outfits the way that she does.

I think she looks better in the ivory dress, too. Not that she isn’t beautiful enough to wear something really hot, but that black outfit just doesn’t work.

I think I speak for men everywhere.

NAUGHTY!

Naughty!!!

That girl has some sexy legs!! That being said she looks beautiful in the ivory but the black is just weird!! Shorts/dresses are just a bad idea, PERIOD!!

Carrie Underwood is a wholesome girl. We need more of them. I’d like her to stay just the way she is. There are too many hot chicks already. Don’t spoil her charm with sexy outfits and hairdos. It warms my heart to see a girl who hasn’t been spoiled by hollywood. Stay fresh and charming, Carrie. We love you.

NICE!!

NAUGHTY.. does look good as well, love the legs, but the nice is alot nicer :P

I love BOTH! Carrie is smokin’ hot either way, and she is a FANTASTIC artist!!!

I dont think it matters like they said shes beautiful and it doesnt matter what she performs in it mtters how she performs! shes amazing eather way!

She is so cute but if you noticed she stepped on her black outfit and had to stop for a brief moment to gain control. If your onstage you need to wear something less obtrusive.

Who knew the girl had nice legs? Lol.. Carrie looks great in the white dress, but she should of chosen some different type of shoes. Maybe some peep toe pumps?

not too many people could pull off either of the outfits…I think she looks fantastic in both!

she looks adorable either way…it doesnt matter whether she is naighty or nice…its a good thing that she changes it up a bit!

She has cute legs! Who knew?

Is it just me, or has she lost a lot of weight? It wouldn’t hurt her to eat a little…
I myself am small (5’5 and 100lbs) but so many celebs lose large amounts of weight and become grossly skinny…Lindsay Lohan, Nicole Richie etc. It’s obvious that some of them don’t even need to lose weight in the first place, and it looks to me like they probably aren’t doing it in the best of ways…Anyway that’s what I think :)

I have always been a huge fan of hers, and this just made it bigger! I love her in both outfits and she brightened the night up a bit. I loved that!

Carrie is beautiful inside and out! I prefer the sweet look, that’s who she is and I hope that she stays true to herself and her Oklahoma roots! :)

She looks great either way, although the black outfit was a little crazy looking. She has some smokin’ legs. You know that got her working her tail off to get legs like that.
But what was up with that hair? She has beautiful hair and then it looked as though it was all slicked down. Leave it long and curly!

I don’t like her at all! Bleh!

She can definitley rock both looks.

She’s always in “wholesome southern country” outfits so it’s nice to see her in something with a bit more edge.

Carrie is FREAKIN gorgeous!!!!! it doesnt matter what she wears. She did look better in the dress, though, b/c it really fits her image. shes gorgeous!!!!!!

Amazing.. When she stood up I was like WOW!! Her legs are amazing! Bitter..party of one:) loved both looks, she works hard on her bod and she was tasteful not tacky.

SHE LOOKS BEAUTIFUL EITHER WAY, BUT I APPRECIATE HER LETTING HER WILD SIDE SHINE THROUGH. IT REALLY SHOWS THAT SHE’S NOT SCARED TO TRY NEW THINGS BY EXPRESSING HERSELF THROUGH HER OUTFITS. CARRIE IS GORGEOUS NO MATTER WHAT SHE DOES!

oeeeh I LOVE that right dress! So I can’t pick naughty or nice but I wanna have a dress like the naughty one haha! awesome!

She looks great in the black outfit. I don’t see anything naughty about it. The white dress it’s beautiful, however she should had made a better shoe choice. The sandals did not match the elegance of the dress. My choice is the BLACK Dress!!!!

I think she looks good in both pictures… I would kill to look like her… I think its her apperance more then he outfit that makes her beautiful

personally, i like the red carpet look. : ]

She looks great either way. Though the black outfit is anything but ‘naughty’! There’s probably more fabric in that ‘table cover’ of hers than there is all together on her ivory dress.

I luv carrie underwood either way.. shes a total beauty and shes still young let ehr experience new styles:P

i think she is goreous.eve when she wears sexy cloths, she looks amazing

Carrie looks excellent in both styles. She has great legs, and the black shorts/gown definitely do not make her look naughty. Just stand her next to Mariah Carey and watch her halo appear!

I think she is gorgeous and looks great in both outfits, but the black dress-ish thing is just ugly. If she wants to show some skin, she has every right to, but please, next time, do it with a little more taste.

Personally, I think she looks absolutely beautiful either way, but I like the nice look much better.

I like the ivory dress better and i really dont like the black dress. But i LOVE the naughty oufit she has in the music video “Before he Cheats”

I just don’t get how shorts are “Nauhgty”?!!! it’s really stupid if you think they are!

Carrie Underwood looks awesome in anything she wears!

I think she looks awesome in both outfits. Not many people can pull it off like she did. She’s a southern girl and they got attitude and style so both outfits look great on her!

I THINK SHE IS SO BEAUTIFUL AND TALENTED IT REALLY DOESN’T MATTER WHAT SHE HAS ON. I THINK IT IS FUN TO BE HOT SOMETIMES, AND SOMETIMES TO BE JUST BEAUTIFUL OR DRESSED UP. SHE IS ALWAYS BEAUTIFUL BECAUSE IT COMES FROM WITHIN HER. SHE SHOULD WEAR WHAT EVER SHE WANTS.

HARRIET

I think she is a beautiful young lady and even when she dresses “naughty”, it’s still pretty tame. I love both looks and since she was singing a medley of her songs, it made sense to have an outfit that addressed the “theme” of all of the songs. I think it was very smart to have the formal dress look for the first two sweet songs then get up and have the other look for “Before He Cheats”. I was actually thinking when she was singing the other two songs that there had to be a wardrobe change coming for the last song since the formal dress look didn’t fit – maybe a tearaway of some sort — when she got up, of course, it made sense… it’s not like she’s ever going to wear the dress again, anyway…

I like both!

carrie looks great to both of her dresses. she is pretty thats what makes her look beautiful. Her sound realy good in the awards show.

deffinatley naughty.. it shows a new and improved side to her nice self twenty-four seven!!

I like her both ways. Sexy with a lil sas, but sweet an inncoent. Depending on what shes doing she looks great!!

You men are hilarious! But I would have to agree with most of you men and would have to say she looks unique and quite hot in the black dress. It was an amazing change, and very sexy when she stood up and showed the shorts. She’s beautiful either way though!!!!!

i love both of her outfits there both really cute

Dear Carrie,
I really think you should stay with your nice look! It looks much better! Your not one of those show off people! So don’t act like it. Your a gordgouse girl! so Please…
Stay like one of those gordgouse, nice girls! and don’t be a snobby girl!

I think that she looks much better NICE! She is such a pretty girl that she doesn’t need to wear NAUGHTY to pull off a good look. We like the wholesome look for a change. Keep it up Carrie! We love you!

Carrie needs to keep the classy yet sexy look. Classy doesn’t mean she has to dress like a nun but at the same time keeping it sexy without revealing too much is her best look. Her voice sells her, she doesn’t need to expose anything to give her music better exposure. I’m glad she is having such wonderful success. She is a good role model for girls and women alike. Keep it up Carrie!!!!

I think she looks good in both outfits. But in this case I would choose the outfit which she is wearing for the American Music Awards becuase it looks sophisticated and elegant.

If you look as good as she does, you can wear whatever you want!!

Either way… she is beautiful inside and out. Her voice is incredible… and that’s what should count above everything else including her appearance (i don’t care what the media says)
Keep climbing your way to the top Carrie… You can do it!

I think Carrie is great!!!! She’s beautiful in anything she wears. Go Carrie, We love you!!!

I think she looks great all the time that girl knows how to dress and make herself look gorgious!!!!!!!!!!!!!

she looks beautiful either way!

She looks pretty good in both but she looks better in the white dress, whereas the black dress looks too much like a Halloween costume.

Nice… ’cause it’s so sweat!

carrie is gorgeous. she pulls of the ivory dress a lot better but that may be a function of that awful black concoction. i think she could go for more scandalous but it is not the image she originally wanted to portray as a country gal. anything she wears looks great.

I think Carrie pulled off both looks! The ivory dress was GORGEOUS! With the black outfit, she was dressing for the song. It was fun to see her be a little more sassy. She looks great!

I think that Carrie looks a lot better in the “nice” outfit. She is such a talented person that she shoudn’t have to “sell her body” in order to display her talents. There are very few young women in Hollywood that I can truely say display role model characteristics. I think that Carrie is one of the few who actually are wholesome, kind-hearted, well intentioned women. We need more women like her in the world. Stick to being nice!

Either way she’s awesome!! Carrie could wear a flour sack and it would look great-as for Cathy/Nov. 23rd comment-Carrie is the American in Apple pie! Bleh to your comment.

I like her nice look better- not a big fan of the short shorts under an open ball gown skirt.

Carrie is a beautiful, talented young lady. I think that both outfits she has on look GREAT on her and still lady like. The only thing I hope is she doesn’t go farther than thatt. I can see myself quite dissapointed to see her take it to far and start dressing as “others” in that industry. That would make me quite dissapointed. I definately think that Carries style choice should be more of the red carpet look seen above, but I don’t think that the other outfit would be considered bad girl. I think she looks great in both!

I like her better when she is dressed nice. She is beautiful either way but she has a sort of innocence that seems lost when she dresses naughty.

I think she is a beautiful, beautiful girl! I just don’t think either outfit is very flattering especially the stage outfit with the shorts/dress combo. I think whom ever suggested that outfit should be fired! Such a waste on a beautiful girl. She is such a great canvas to work with so WORK IT!!!

Both!

I hate both of her outfits and she is not a good singer
and just so so looking.

I like Carrie looking sweet, I hope she doesn’t change too much. I didn’t like it when Kelly changed to sexy either.

I think she looks hot either way but that black dress/short thing isn’t working for me. what was her stylist thinking?!

I love her body, and I think she can pull anything off. If she wants to be naughty, then go for it. As long as it’s not like Christina Aguilera’s “Dirrty”! The sweet country girl look is adorable, and she looks great in that too! It also reflects her personality a little better.

BOTH!

I think she looks good in both, but she looks great and more comfortable in the dress. I think the naughty isn’t the image she said she was trying to portray. If anyone saw her perform during the Dallas Cowboy’s half time show, the thigh high boots didn’t suit her either. But she has talent!

I like both looks the sweet and the edgier look you can do
both it’s not bad to do that

I love her music & I love her style sence peiod. She has a great voice and that’s really what matters!

well i like the sexy look but i like her old sweet look you know the one she had a couple weeks after she won american idol. that was sexy, sweet, and i liked it alot… she was the one celebrity that i could look up to and that i could afford to look like! she WAS the person i looked up to as a romodel and i really miss her sweet small town girl thing!

im her little sis!I love her every single way!Love you Carrie!

I think Carrie looks beutiful on the red carpet and to sexy in the other picture. And i’m a big fan of Carrie’s and all the other country singers. Your a great singer and have a beutiful voice.

She’s going to be like Faith Hill wear anything and everything anyway she wants!

I think Carrie looks better in the pink dress, because the other outfit just doesn’t fit her personality.

i dont know i like her both ways i think the dress is more of the country image she wanted so bad but she has an amazeing body that would look good in everything.i do think she needs a different hairstyle i liked her long paris hilton looking hair she had after winning american idol

I think she looks amazing in both but i prefer the pink dress

Why can’t you be a little of both? Naughty & nice…

Naughty? I don’t really see that as naughty the only thing she is showing more of is legs, how is that naughty? She looks great either way and I’m glad to see she can be versatile.

WOW either way! Yummy and sweet and naughty all at the same time

Carrie is beautiful and there is no other way to put it. No matter what she’s in, she just has a natural beauty and can make anything look amazing. Go girl!!!!!

i think carrie looks better sweet and i did not like her little trashy outfit.

She looks good….period! Of course she must change her looks otherwise too boring. She can handle it!!! just don’t expose private body parts……like some of the others out there. I think she is grand.

She looks awesome either way! Go Carrie!!! P.S. My 3 yr old daughter LOVES you!!!

She looks great any where at any time! Plus, Carrie is my life so whatever she’s wearing it always looks good! You go sister!!!

She looks so beautiful in her dress. this is coming from a girl from the south and we know you dont have to wear reveling close to be sexy. i think she rocked the nice look. YOU GO GIRL!

She looks great both styles. Good for her for showing both at one event! Plus, if people know the song ‘Before He Cheats’ it’s not a ‘nice girl’ song. That black outfit was totally appropriate for the performance!

i think she looked good in both of the dressses.

I think she looks stunning in the ivory dress. She wears the bustier ballgown nicely, although I think she is way more conservative in the dress. It doesn’t matter, her voice is amazing and celebrity styles are bound to change.

Carrie……you will look grerat in anytjing you wear, your BEAUTIFUL!! You rock both looks.

I think she looks beautiful either way. And I don’t think she’s going to keep that bad girl image, I believe it’s just for that one naughty girl song she has out. But she’s just stunning no matter what!

I think she should dress to match the real her. From what we know, she is avery sweet and kindhearted, pleasant girl. So I say NICE! Of course, because we really don’t know her personally, she may be trying to play off many types of personalities. She is a very talented and cute girl either way.

I think she looked spectacular in both outfits! It was kind of a nice and naughty theme for the evening. She was angelic and pure before the performance, she turned into a naughty diva for her performance, and then it was all sweet and innocent again. I loved it!

I think that she looks trashy in the naughty outfit but, super cut in the nice out fit. Carrie go with nice not naughty!!

I think that Carry is a very luky lady, because personally, she looks gorgeous either way. There’s very few people who can pull off both the naughty and flrity look.

I think Carrie rocks either way. She’s beautiful whatever she wears, I’m totally jealous. She’s very talented in her music career. She’s gone very far in the time she’s been around. No wonder why some women are jealous, lol.

CARRIE, YOU LOOK AWESOME EITHER WAY !!! WHO KNEW YOU HAVE SUCH GREAT LEGS???!!!!!!! IF YOU GOT IT FLAUNT IT !!!

Carrie Underwood is amazing! She is very talented, very beautiful and she looks great in anything.

Both look great! She isn’t going for the “I’m a bad girl” look or trying to be like the old Christina. She is showing that “good” girls can be sexy too and not look like a tramp. She’s beautiful!

I am a big fan of Carrie and I really liked the look.. I think that she looks good in what ever she wears…. CARRIE YOU ROCK!!!!!!

i think she looks fabulous either way it is not that trashy the second dress if anything she looks like a million dollars

With LEGS like that, honey…Naughty is a MUST!!!

I prefer the nice look. I feel that it suits her persona more so than the naughty outfit.

I have always been a big fan of Carrie. Her naughty look was not the best

Carrie Underwood might not be able to sing “Jesus Take the Wheel” in the naughty outfit, but could you imagine her singing “Before He Cheats” in the nice one? I can’t, but she looks absolutely gorgeous in both!

With a voice like Carrie’s she can wear whatever she wants to. She’s got it, she might as well show it off!

I think she looks great both ways! She is young and allowed to wear whatever she wants and I think anyone knocking the black outfit is probably jusy jealous they dont have the body for it!

i think shes greatt and i like her a lot so what ever to tha haters out there who, yo like, dont dig tha most rocking outfit of the year. what??? holaa!!

Carrie definatly looks better naughty!!! It just brings out her innner child goddessness!!!

I like her naughty much better because Carrie Underwood is a better naughty girl.

your the best we really enjoy everything you do!

I love your latest video. I always have the country music channel on tv when I’m getting ready and always have to stop what I’m doing to watch… you go girl.

totally spice over sugar! She looks completely sexy and vampiric

CRAZY………………..

i love carie how she is always down to earth but when she wears that black dress it looks trashy hay but who knew she had great legs!!

She’s amazing, very talented and oh so beautiful.
But I think Naughty is better, specially if we get to see those legs.

GO NAUGHTY CARRIE!!

I think she is a beautiful woman in what ever she chooses to waer.She is a real person from the herat she is a nice country girl.She has values and faith.

I like the black lacy dress the best. It shows off her legs.

well i think she looks better when she is nice. I think this because she is such a sweet girl. Even though she is beautiful both ways. Well I LOVE Carrie Underwood!! So any way she dresses she is still someone i look up to!

She looks great no matter what. She’s always YOUNG AND BEAUTIFUL!! I LOVE YOU CARRIE!!!!

If i didint know who she was i whold say both,, But Carrie Is the “Nice” Girl,, But i Think She looks Great in Both but Nice is more like Her :D

Carrie has a beautiful body and I wish that I had that body. The ivory dress looks gorgeous on her and matches her perfectly. But that black dress that she wore with the shorts does not work out.

I so loved her dress that she had on the red carpet. It fit her personaliy very well. The whole “Naughty” thing just doesn’t fit her.

I think Carrie can wear anything and have the look. She is simply beautiful inside and out!!

I don’t think her naughty is that naughty. She always covers herself up real good. She’s just wearing dress shorts with a nice shirt with a long train on it.

I think Carrie looked beautiful in both outfits. It’s nice to see a little wild side come out sometimes.

Personally, i don’t really like her talent-wise. I’m not a huge fan. But, her white dress is amaaazing, i just HATE her black outfit. At least she has SOME fashion sense.

I think she looks gorgeous either way!!! If I had her legs I would flaunt them as much as I could! She went from sweet little southern girl on AI to this beautiful woman right before America’s eyes! I think she is a very good role modle for all young girls and if she wants to show a little skin sometime I think there is nothing wrong with that. So either way she is a beautiful talented woman!!

I think Carrie is awesome………. She is an awesome singer and has a great body…She would look great anything

I think that she is beautiful . Either outfit works well with her. She is definitly an Idol!!!!

I am for the nice look because that is her appearance and demeanor. It was a shock to see that AMA’s outfit when she sang, but she had to fit the song. She has always looked stunning on the Red Carpet, no worries there. Carrie knows what she is doing and has a good head on her shoulders. She won’t let her fans down! She will always be that breath of fresh air to me!

I love Carrie in the white dress, but honestly, she tries so many different music styles, why not let her have fun with the different dress style. She’s still young enough to get by with it. But I definitely like the dress better. Keep up the good work Carrie!

Trashy is a little bit harsh. she has been the same the whole time i just think that she is getting a little bit more comfortable with herself in the spotlight.

Beautiful…

I think she lokos gorgeous in both. the song “before he cheats” is a more sexier song. the dress goes with the song. she matches her outfits wit the song shes singin.

YOU LOOK GOOD CARRIE.. AND YOUR VOICE IS AMAZIN!!
FINALLY ANOTHER SUCCESSFULL AMERICAN IDOL!!

she looks great in anything!!

Nice….She looks good in both though.

Normally I would think that black outfit wasn’t so great, but she looks hot in it. She can pull off both outfits. She is awesome!!

carrie underwood does not kno how to look naughty

She Looks amazing in both, but I think the naughty looks even better on her, she can pull anything off!!

I think that Carrie is a beautiful person. And that it doesn’t matter what she wears she still looks beautiful. And she still shines through.

I think she looks great both ways. She’s an amazing singer so it doesnt matter what she wears.

NICE any boys that put Naughty are sick-o’s

She is gorgeous but both of those dresses are ugly. She can look “sweet” buy still be a little more sophisticated. The ivory in a sheath would have been better, but lose those ugly white shoes!

I think she looks more sofisticated in the Gown the other one makes her look gothic

I think she looks great in everyoutfit she wears, she has a great body and great voice! :)

i like her “NAKED”

I Like Her The Way She IS She will always be Both. I Like Her Sexy.

soooooooooooooo hot

Nice. Definitely nice.

i think she should wear whatever she likes without people hounding her about what she wears and what looks good.. let her be want she wants to be….

I think that Carrie Underwood looks ok in the white but I have to say that the black fits with her body more so than the nice.

hey i like carrie underwood she is so pretty

I met carrie underwood this past summer! Anyway, I think she looks gorgeous in both. Please, Carrie, don’t get too thin!

i think that she definitely has the legs for the second outfit and it looks good on her. She can pull it off so leave her be. Plus she’s super cute and everyone loves her so it doesn’t matter HAHAH!! I LOVE YOU CARRIE!!

I LOVE HER. i think shes super nice and adorable and shes definitally not annorexic so dont think that :) woo woo!!

I think that Carrie looked better when she was performing because I just think it is more ‘her’…

i think shes absolutely gorgeous either way

I Think She Looks Very Good Either Way She Dressess.

Carrie Underwood,
Stay with God, and don’t go sexy.

Seeing her new video… naughty isn’t too naughty for Carrie. Let’s leave the cowboy casanovas to Carrie, cause she can whip em up and still come back to nice. Let’s hope she DOES come back, though!!

to hot for her look